Many thanks to NetGalley, Celadon Books, and Macmillan Audio for gifting me both a digital and audio ARC of the sophomore book by Caitlin Mullen, with the audiobook wonderfully narrated by the cast of Bailey Carr, Christine Lakin, and Mia Wurgaft. All opinions expressed in this review are my own - 4.5 stars rounded up!
In 1994, in a small town in the New Jersey Pine Barrens, 16-year-old twins Annabelle and Sabrina both disappear. Sabrina had been having an affair with a mysterious older man and Annabelle had her own secrets. Years later in the same small town, new Police Chief Callie Hauser makes an arrest that unexpectedly resurrects details from a cold case. As she digs deeper, the past and present collide.
I love mysteries that take place in small towns, where everyone knows your secrets or at least it feels that way. This is a slow burn, with multiple POV, done perfectly in the audiobook format with different narrators. I felt compassion for the teenage girls and loved Callie’s grit and determination to find answers. This book is tense, and the suspension continues to build throughout the book, with secrets galore and characters that will pull at your heart. Plenty of themes of motherhood throughout. I loved this author’s debut novel, Please See Us, and this one is just as powerful.

